Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6

Dark Arcana: The Carnival vs The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

Critics rate the two games about the same, but players prefer Dark Arcana: The Carnival. The Testament of Sherlock Holmes is the shorter one, at about 9 hours.

Side by side

Dark Arcana: The Carnival compared with The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
MeasureDark Arcana: The CarnivalThe Testament of Sherlock Holmes
Critics–73
Players86 (better)77
Released20122012
Time to beat12 h9 h (better)
GenresPuzzle, AdventurePuzzle, Adventure
Play withSingle-playerSingle-player
PlatformsPC, macOS, PS4, Xbox One, SwitchPC, PS4, PS3, Xbox 360, Switch
DeveloperArtifex MundiFrogwares

Which one should you play?

Pick

Dark Arcana: The Carnival

  • You want something to sink into: about 12 hours against 9.
  • You play on macOS and Xbox One, where The Testament of Sherlock Holmes is not available.
Read about Dark Arcana: The Carnival →

Pick

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

  • You have less time: about 9 hours against 12.
  • You play on PS3 and Xbox 360, where Dark Arcana: The Carnival is not available.
Read about The Testament of Sherlock Holmes →
Compare other games

More like The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

Quick verdicts

Players prefer
Dark Arcana: The Carnival86 v 77
Longer story
Dark Arcana: The Carnival12 h v 9 h
Longer to 100%
Dark Arcana: The Carnival29 h v 13 h
Bigger download
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes14 GB v 1 GB
Co-op
Neither
Better for kids
Dark Arcana: The Carnival
More players now
The Testament of Sherlock Holmeson Steam
More achievements
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes32 v 19
More languages
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes16 v 11

More about Dark Arcana: The Carnival vs The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

Scores

Which do players prefer, Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

Dark Arcana: The Carnival: players rate it 86 against 77 out of 100.

Is Dark Arcana: The Carnival better than The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

Players prefer Dark Arcana: The Carnival.

Time and size

Which is longer, Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

Dark Arcana: The Carnival, at about 12 hours for the main story against 9.

Which takes longer to 100%?

Dark Arcana: The Carnival: about 29 hours to do everything, against 13.

Which is bigger to download, Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes needs about 14 GB on PC, against 1 GB (from their Steam requirements).

Playing

Which has co-op, Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

Neither has co-op.

Which is better for kids, Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

Dark Arcana: The Carnival is rated for younger players (ESRB T, PEGI 7, against ESRB M, PEGI 16).

Is Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes first person?

Dark Arcana: The Carnival is played in first person; The Testament of Sherlock Holmes in first and third person.

Which has more players right now?

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes: 6 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 0. Console players aren't counted.

Platforms

Can I play Dark Arcana: The Carnival and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes on Nintendo Switch?

Yes, both are on Nintendo Switch.

Can I play Dark Arcana: The Carnival and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes on PC?

Yes, both are on PC.

Which platforms have both Dark Arcana: The Carnival and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

PC, PS4 and Switch.

History

Which came out first, Dark Arcana: The Carnival or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes (2012) came out a few months before Dark Arcana: The Carnival (2012).

Who made Dark Arcana: The Carnival and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?

Dark Arcana: The Carnival is by Artifex Mundi; The Testament of Sherlock Holmes is by Frogwares.

What do Dark Arcana: The Carnival and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes have in common?

Both are puzzle and adventure games, and both are on PC, PS4 and Switch.

Extras

Which has more achievements?

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes, with 32 on Steam against 19.

Which supports more languages?

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes, with 16 languages against 11.

Keep going