Machinarium vs The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
Machinarium is rated higher by critics (88 against 73), and players agree. The Testament of Sherlock Holmes is the shorter one, at about 9 hours.
Side by side
| Measure | Machinarium | The Testament of Sherlock Holmes |
|---|---|---|
| Critics | 88 (better) | 73 |
| Players | 95 (better) | 77 |
| Released | 2009 | 2012 |
| Time to beat | 10 h | 9 h (better) |
| Genres | Adventure, Puzzle | Puzzle, Adventure |
| Play with | Single-player | Single-player |
| Platforms | PC, macOS, PS4, PS3, Xbox One | PC, PS4, PS3, Xbox 360, Switch |
| Developer | Amanita Design | Frogwares |
Which one should you play?
Pick
Machinarium
- You want the higher-rated game (88 against 73 from critics).
- You want something to sink into: about 10 hours against 9.
- You play on macOS and Xbox One, where The Testament of Sherlock Holmes is not available.
Pick
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
- You have less time: about 9 hours against 10.
- You play on Xbox 360, where Machinarium is not available.
- You want the newer game (2012 against 2009).
Quick verdicts
- Critics prefer
- Machinarium88 v 73
- Players prefer
- Machinarium95 v 77
- Longer story
- Machinarium10 h v 9 h
- Longer to 100%
- Machinarium24 h v 13 h
- Bigger download
- The Testament of Sherlock Holmes14 GB v 1 GB
- Co-op
- Neither
- Better for kids
- Machinarium
- Steam Deck
- MachinariumVerified v Playable
- More players now
- Machinariumon Steam
- More platforms
- Machinarium6 v 5
- Newer
- The Testament of Sherlock Holmes2012
- More achievements
- The Testament of Sherlock Holmes32 v 12
More about Machinarium vs The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
Scores
Which do critics rate higher, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Machinarium: 88 against 73.
Which do players prefer, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Machinarium: players rate it 95 against 77 out of 100.
Is Machinarium better than The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
By the numbers, Machinarium is better: critics and players both rate it higher.
Time and size
Which is longer, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Machinarium, at about 10 hours for the main story against 9.
Which takes longer to 100%?
Machinarium: about 24 hours to do everything, against 13.
Which is bigger to download, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes needs about 14 GB on PC, against 1 GB (from their Steam requirements).
Playing
Which has co-op, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Neither has co-op.
Which is better for kids, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Machinarium is rated for younger players (ESRB E10+, PEGI 7, against ESRB M, PEGI 16).
Which runs better on Steam Deck?
Machinarium (Verified), against Playable.
Which has more players right now?
Machinarium: 70 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 6. Console players aren't counted.
Platforms
Can I play Machinarium and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes on Nintendo Switch?
Yes, both are on Nintendo Switch.
Can I play Machinarium and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes on PC?
Yes, both are on PC.
Which platforms have both Machinarium and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
PC, PS4, PS3 and Switch.
History
Which came out first, Machinarium or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Machinarium (2009) came out 3 years before The Testament of Sherlock Holmes (2012).
Who made Machinarium and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes?
Machinarium is by Amanita Design; The Testament of Sherlock Holmes is by Frogwares.
What do Machinarium and The Testament of Sherlock Holmes have in common?
Both are adventure and puzzle games, and both are on PC, PS4 and PS3.
Extras
Which has more achievements?
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes, with 32 on Steam against 12.
Which has more DLC?
Machinarium, with 1 DLC items on Steam against 0.

