Mad Father vs Pony Island
Critics rate the two games about the same, but players prefer Mad Father. Pony Island is the shorter one, at about 3 hours.
Side by side
| Measure | Mad Father | Pony Island |
|---|---|---|
| Critics | – | 86 |
| Players | 98 (better) | 94 |
| Released | 2016 | 2016 |
| Time to beat | 45 h | 3 h (better) |
| Genres | Horror, Puzzle, RPG | Puzzle, Horror, Indie |
| Play with | Single-player | Single-player |
| Platforms | PC, Switch | PC, macOS |
| Developer | Sen | Daniel Mullins Games |
Which one should you play?
Pick
Mad Father
- You want something to sink into: about 45 hours against 3.
- You play on Switch, where Pony Island is not available.
- You are in a story-first mood.
Pick
Pony Island
- You have less time: about 3 hours against 45.
- You play on macOS, where Mad Father is not available.
- You are in a relaxed mood.
More like Pony Island
Quick verdicts
- Players prefer
- Mad Father98 v 94
- Longer story
- Mad Father45 h v 3 h
- Longer to 100%
- Mad Father108 h v 4 h
- Bigger download
- Pony Island0.4 GB v 0.1 GB
- Co-op
- Neither
- Steam Deck
- Both Verified
- More players now
- Pony Islandon Steam
- More achievements
- Mad Father21 v 20
- More languages
- Pony Island12 v 6
More about Mad Father vs Pony Island
Scores
Which do players prefer, Mad Father or Pony Island?
Mad Father: players rate it 98 against 94 out of 100.
Is Mad Father better than Pony Island?
Players prefer Mad Father.
Time and size
Which is longer, Mad Father or Pony Island?
Mad Father, at about 45 hours for the main story against 3.
Which takes longer to 100%?
Mad Father: about 108 hours to do everything, against 4.
Which is bigger to download, Mad Father or Pony Island?
Pony Island needs about 0.4 GB on PC, against 0.1 GB (from their Steam requirements).
Playing
Which has co-op, Mad Father or Pony Island?
Neither has co-op.
Which runs better on Steam Deck?
Both are rated Verified on Steam Deck.
Which has more players right now?
Pony Island: 77 people were playing on Steam on 13 November, against 11. Console players aren't counted.
Platforms
Can I play Mad Father and Pony Island on Nintendo Switch?
Only Mad Father is on Nintendo Switch.
Can I play Mad Father and Pony Island on PC?
Yes, both are on PC.
Which platforms have both Mad Father and Pony Island?
PC.
History
Which came out first, Mad Father or Pony Island?
Pony Island (2016) came out a few months before Mad Father (2016).
Who made Mad Father and Pony Island?
Mad Father is by Sen; Pony Island is by Daniel Mullins Games.
What do Mad Father and Pony Island have in common?
Both are horror and puzzle games, and both are on PC.
Extras
Which has more achievements?
Mad Father, with 21 on Steam against 20.
Which has more DLC?
Pony Island, with 1 DLC items on Steam against 0.
Which supports more languages?
Pony Island, with 12 languages against 6.





