Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6

Mafia: Definitive Edition vs Mafia III

Mafia: Definitive Edition is rated higher by critics (78 against 62), and players agree. Mafia: Definitive Edition is the shorter one, at about 11 hours.

Side by side

Mafia: Definitive Edition compared with Mafia III
MeasureMafia: Definitive EditionMafia III
Critics78 (better)62
Players87 (better)62
Released20202016
Time to beat11 h (better)48 h
GenresAction-Adventure, Crime, NarrativeOpen World, Action-Adventure, Crime
Play withSingle-playerSingle-player
PlatformsPC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox OnePC, macOS, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S
DeveloperHangar 13Hangar 13

Which one should you play?

Pick

Mafia: Definitive Edition

  • You want the higher-rated game (78 against 62 from critics).
  • You have less time: about 11 hours against 48.
  • You want the newer game (2020 against 2016).
Read about Mafia: Definitive Edition →

Pick

Mafia III

  • You want something to sink into: about 48 hours against 11.
  • You play on macOS, where Mafia: Definitive Edition is not available.
  • You prefer Open World games.
Read about Mafia III →
Compare other games

Quick verdicts

Critics prefer
Mafia: Definitive Edition78 v 62
Players prefer
Mafia: Definitive Edition87 v 62
Longer story
Mafia III48 h v 11 h
Longer to 100%
Mafia III48 h v 32 h
Bigger download
Same50 GB v 50 GB
Co-op
Neither
Better for kids
Similar
Steam Deck
Both Playable
More players now
Mafia IIIon Steam
More platforms
Mafia III6 v 5
Newer
Mafia: Definitive Edition2020
More achievements
Mafia III85 v 43

More about Mafia: Definitive Edition vs Mafia III

Scores

Which do critics rate higher, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

Mafia: Definitive Edition: 78 against 62.

Which do players prefer, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

Mafia: Definitive Edition: players rate it 87 against 62 out of 100.

Is Mafia: Definitive Edition better than Mafia III?

By the numbers, Mafia: Definitive Edition is better: critics and players both rate it higher.

Time and size

Which is longer, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

Mafia III, at about 48 hours for the main story against 11.

Which takes longer to 100%?

Mafia III: about 48 hours to do everything, against 32.

Which is bigger to download, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

Both need about 50 GB on PC.

Playing

Which has co-op, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

Neither has co-op.

Which is better for kids, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

They carry similar age ratings (ESRB M, PEGI 18 and ESRB M, PEGI 18).

Is Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III first person?

Both are played in third person.

Which runs better on Steam Deck?

Both are rated Playable on Steam Deck.

Which has more players right now?

Mafia III: 1,158 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 724. Console players aren't counted.

Platforms

Can I play Mafia: Definitive Edition and Mafia III on PS5?

Yes, both are on PS5.

Can I play Mafia: Definitive Edition and Mafia III on Xbox Series X/S?

Yes, both are on Xbox Series X/S.

Can I play Mafia: Definitive Edition and Mafia III on PC?

Yes, both are on PC.

Which platforms have both Mafia: Definitive Edition and Mafia III?

PC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S and Xbox One.

History

Which came out first, Mafia: Definitive Edition or Mafia III?

Mafia III (2016) came out 4 years before Mafia: Definitive Edition (2020).

Should I play Mafia III before Mafia: Definitive Edition?

They're in the same series, and Mafia III came first (2016). Playing in release order is the safe choice, though each usually stands on its own.

Are Mafia: Definitive Edition and Mafia III made by the same studio?

Yes, both are by Hangar 13.

What do Mafia: Definitive Edition and Mafia III have in common?

Both are action-adventure and crime games, and both are on PC, PS5 and PS4.

Extras

Which has more achievements?

Mafia III, with 85 on Steam against 43.

Which has more DLC?

Mafia: Definitive Edition, with 1 DLC items on Steam against 0.

Keep going