Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6

Mafia II vs Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption is rated higher by critics (95 against 77), and players agree. Mafia II is the shorter one, at about 16 hours.

Side by side

Mafia II compared with Red Dead Redemption
MeasureMafia IIRed Dead Redemption
Critics7795 (better)
Players9192 (better)
Released20102010
Time to beat16 h (better)25 h
GenresAction-Adventure, CrimeAction-Adventure, Open World
Play withSingle-playerSingle-player, Multiplayer
PlatformsPC, PS3, Xbox 360PC, PS3, Xbox 360
Developer2K CzechRockstar San Diego

Which one should you play?

Pick

Mafia II

  • You have less time: about 16 hours against 25.
  • You prefer Crime games.
Read about Mafia II →

Pick

Red Dead Redemption

  • You want the higher-rated game (95 against 77 from critics).
  • You want something to sink into: about 25 hours against 16.
  • You prefer Open World games.
Read about Red Dead Redemption →
Compare other games

More like Mafia II

Quick verdicts

Critics prefer
Red Dead Redemption95 v 77
Players prefer
Red Dead Redemption92 v 91
Longer story
Red Dead Redemption25 h v 16 h
Longer to 100%
Red Dead Redemption46 h v 39 h
Bigger download
Red Dead Redemption12 GB v 8 GB
Co-op
Neither
Better for kids
Similar
Steam Deck
Red Dead RedemptionUnsupported v Playable
More players now
Red Dead Redemptionon Steam
More achievements
Mafia II67 v 51
More languages
Red Dead Redemption13 v 8

More about Mafia II vs Red Dead Redemption

Scores

Which do critics rate higher, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

Red Dead Redemption: 95 against 77.

Which do players prefer, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

Red Dead Redemption: players rate it 92 against 91 out of 100.

Is Mafia II better than Red Dead Redemption?

By the numbers, Red Dead Redemption is better: critics and players both rate it higher.

Time and size

Which is longer, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

Red Dead Redemption, at about 25 hours for the main story against 16.

Which takes longer to 100%?

Red Dead Redemption: about 46 hours to do everything, against 39.

Which is bigger to download, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

Red Dead Redemption needs about 12 GB on PC, against 8 GB (from their Steam requirements).

Playing

Which has co-op, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

Neither has co-op.

Which is better for kids, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

They carry similar age ratings (ESRB M, PEGI 18 and ESRB M, PEGI 18).

Is Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption first person?

Both are played in third person.

Which runs better on Steam Deck?

Red Dead Redemption (Playable), against Unsupported.

Which has more players right now?

Red Dead Redemption: 718 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 308. Console players aren't counted.

Platforms

Can I play Mafia II and Red Dead Redemption on PC?

Yes, both are on PC.

Which platforms have both Mafia II and Red Dead Redemption?

PC, PS3 and Xbox 360.

History

Which came out first, Mafia II or Red Dead Redemption?

Red Dead Redemption (2010) came out a few months before Mafia II (2010).

Who made Mafia II and Red Dead Redemption?

Mafia II is by 2K Czech; Red Dead Redemption is by Rockstar San Diego.

What do Mafia II and Red Dead Redemption have in common?

Both are action-adventure games, and both are on PC, PS3 and Xbox 360.

Extras

Which has more achievements?

Mafia II, with 67 on Steam against 51.

Which supports more languages?

Red Dead Redemption, with 13 languages against 8.

Keep going