Penumbra: Black Plague vs Shatter
Shatter is rated higher by critics (84 against 78), and players agree. Shatter is the shorter one, at about 10 hours.
Side by side
| Measure | Penumbra: Black Plague | Shatter |
|---|---|---|
| Critics | 78 | 84 (better) |
| Players | 93 | 95 (better) |
| Released | 2008 | 2009 |
| Time to beat | 10 h | 10 h |
| Genres | Puzzle, Sci-Fi, Horror | Puzzle, Sci-Fi |
| Play with | Single-player | Single-player, Co-op, Multiplayer |
| Platforms | PC, macOS | PC, macOS, PS3 |
| Developer | Frictional Games | Sidhe Interactive |
Which one should you play?
Pick
Penumbra: Black Plague
- You are in a cinematic mood.
- You prefer Horror games.
Pick
Shatter
- You want the higher-rated game (84 against 78 from critics).
- You want to play with a friend, since it has co-op and the other does not.
- You play on PS3, where Penumbra: Black Plague is not available.
More like Penumbra: Black Plague
Quick verdicts
- Critics prefer
- Shatter84 v 78
- Players prefer
- Shatter95 v 93
- Longer story
- Same10 h v 10 h
- Co-op
- Shatter
- Better for kids
- Shatter
- Steam Deck
- Both Playable
- More players now
- Penumbra: Black Plagueon Steam
- More platforms
- Shatter3 v 2
- Newer
- Shatter2009
- More achievements
- Shatter30 v 0
- More languages
- Shatter5 v 1
More about Penumbra: Black Plague vs Shatter
Scores
Which do critics rate higher, Penumbra: Black Plague or Shatter?
Shatter: 84 against 78.
Which do players prefer, Penumbra: Black Plague or Shatter?
Shatter: players rate it 95 against 93 out of 100.
Is Penumbra: Black Plague better than Shatter?
By the numbers, Shatter is better: critics and players both rate it higher.
Time and size
Which is longer, Penumbra: Black Plague or Shatter?
About the same: roughly 10 hours each for the main story.
Playing
Which has co-op, Penumbra: Black Plague or Shatter?
Shatter has co-op; Penumbra: Black Plague doesn't.
Which is better for kids, Penumbra: Black Plague or Shatter?
Shatter is rated for younger players (ESRB E, PEGI 3, against ESRB M, PEGI 16).
Which runs better on Steam Deck?
Both are rated Playable on Steam Deck.
Which has more players right now?
Penumbra: Black Plague: 6 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 0. Console players aren't counted.
Platforms
Can I play Penumbra: Black Plague and Shatter on PC?
Yes, both are on PC.
Which platforms have both Penumbra: Black Plague and Shatter?
PC and macOS.
History
Which came out first, Penumbra: Black Plague or Shatter?
Penumbra: Black Plague (2008) came out 1 year before Shatter (2009).
Who made Penumbra: Black Plague and Shatter?
Penumbra: Black Plague is by Frictional Games; Shatter is by Sidhe Interactive.
What do Penumbra: Black Plague and Shatter have in common?
Both are puzzle and sci-fi games, and both are on PC and macOS.
Extras
Which has more achievements?
Shatter, with 30 on Steam against 0.
Which has more DLC?
Shatter, with 1 DLC items on Steam against 0.
Which supports more languages?
Shatter, with 5 languages against 1.





