Pokémon Black Version vs Pokémon HeartGold Version
Critics rate the two games about the same, but players prefer Pokémon HeartGold Version. Pokémon HeartGold Version is the shorter one, at about 45 hours.
Side by side
| Measure | Pokémon Black Version | Pokémon HeartGold Version |
|---|---|---|
| Critics | 87 | 87 |
| Players | 81 | 88 (better) |
| Released | 2010 | 2009 |
| Time to beat | 45 h | 45 h |
| Genres | RPG, Turn-Based, Fantasy | RPG, Turn-Based, Fantasy |
| Play with | Single-player, Multiplayer | Single-player, Multiplayer |
| Platforms | DS | DS |
| Developer | Game Freak | Game Freak |
Which one should you play?
Pick
Pokémon Black Version
- You want the newer game (2010 against 2009).
Pick
Pokémon HeartGold Version
These two are very close. Go with the one that looks more like your kind of game.
Read about Pokémon HeartGold Version →Quick verdicts
- Critics prefer
- Same87 v 87
- Players prefer
- Pokémon HeartGold Version88 v 81
- Longer story
- Same45 h v 45 h
- Co-op
- Neither
- Better for kids
- Similar
- Newer
- Pokémon Black Version2010
More about Pokémon Black Version vs Pokémon HeartGold Version
Scores
Which do critics rate higher, Pokémon Black Version or Pokémon HeartGold Version?
Critics rate them the same (87).
Which do players prefer, Pokémon Black Version or Pokémon HeartGold Version?
Pokémon HeartGold Version: players rate it 88 against 81 out of 100.
Is Pokémon Black Version better than Pokémon HeartGold Version?
Players prefer Pokémon HeartGold Version.
Time and size
Which is longer, Pokémon Black Version or Pokémon HeartGold Version?
About the same: roughly 45 hours each for the main story.
Playing
Which has co-op, Pokémon Black Version or Pokémon HeartGold Version?
Neither has co-op.
Which is better for kids, Pokémon Black Version or Pokémon HeartGold Version?
They carry similar age ratings (ESRB E, PEGI 3 and ESRB E, PEGI 3).
Platforms
Which platforms have both Pokémon Black Version and Pokémon HeartGold Version?
DS.
History
Which came out first, Pokémon Black Version or Pokémon HeartGold Version?
Pokémon HeartGold Version (2009) came out 1 year before Pokémon Black Version (2010).
Should I play Pokémon HeartGold Version before Pokémon Black Version?
They're in the same series, and Pokémon HeartGold Version came first (2009). Playing in release order is the safe choice, though each usually stands on its own.
Are Pokémon Black Version and Pokémon HeartGold Version made by the same studio?
Yes, both are by Game Freak.
What do Pokémon Black Version and Pokémon HeartGold Version have in common?
Both are RPG, turn-based and fantasy games, and both are on DS.

