Pony Island vs We Were Here
Critics rate the two games about the same, but players prefer Pony Island. We Were Here is the shorter one, at about 2 hours.
Side by side
| Measure | Pony Island | We Were Here |
|---|---|---|
| Critics | 86 | – |
| Players | 94 (better) | 90 |
| Released | 2016 | 2017 |
| Time to beat | 3 h | 2 h (better) |
| Genres | Puzzle, Horror, Indie | Puzzle, Horror |
| Play with | Single-player | Single-player, Co-op, Multiplayer |
| Platforms | PC, macOS | PC, macOS, PS5, PS4, Xbox One |
| Developer | Daniel Mullins Games | Total Mayhem Games |
Which one should you play?
Pick
Pony Island
- You want something to sink into: about 3 hours against 2.
- You prefer Indie games.
Pick
We Were Here
- You have less time: about 2 hours against 3.
- You want to play with a friend, since it has co-op and the other does not.
- You play on PS5 and PS4, where Pony Island is not available.
More like Pony Island
Quick verdicts
- Players prefer
- Pony Island94 v 90
- Longer story
- Pony Island3 h v 2 h
- Longer to 100%
- Pony Island4 h v 2 h
- Bigger download
- We Were Here4 GB v 0.4 GB
- Co-op
- We Were Here
- Steam Deck
- Pony IslandVerified v Playable
- More players now
- We Were Hereon Steam
- More platforms
- We Were Here6 v 2
- Newer
- We Were Here2017
- More achievements
- We Were Here26 v 20
- More languages
- We Were Here22 v 12
More about Pony Island vs We Were Here
Scores
Which do players prefer, Pony Island or We Were Here?
Pony Island: players rate it 94 against 90 out of 100.
Is Pony Island better than We Were Here?
Players prefer Pony Island.
Time and size
Which is longer, Pony Island or We Were Here?
Pony Island, at about 3 hours for the main story against 2.
Which takes longer to 100%?
Pony Island: about 4 hours to do everything, against 2.
Which is bigger to download, Pony Island or We Were Here?
We Were Here needs about 4 GB on PC, against 0.4 GB (from their Steam requirements).
Playing
Which has co-op, Pony Island or We Were Here?
We Were Here has co-op; Pony Island doesn't.
Which runs better on Steam Deck?
Pony Island (Verified), against Playable.
Which has more players right now?
We Were Here: 270 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 77. Console players aren't counted.
Which is free to play?
We Were Here is free to play on Steam; Pony Island is paid.
Platforms
Can I play Pony Island and We Were Here on Nintendo Switch?
Only We Were Here is on Nintendo Switch.
Can I play Pony Island and We Were Here on PS5?
Only We Were Here is on PS5.
Can I play Pony Island and We Were Here on PC?
Yes, both are on PC.
Which platforms have both Pony Island and We Were Here?
PC and macOS.
History
Which came out first, Pony Island or We Were Here?
Pony Island (2016) came out 1 year before We Were Here (2017).
Who made Pony Island and We Were Here?
Pony Island is by Daniel Mullins Games; We Were Here is by Total Mayhem Games.
What do Pony Island and We Were Here have in common?
Both are puzzle and horror games, and both are on PC and macOS.
Extras
Which has more achievements?
We Were Here, with 26 on Steam against 20.
Which supports more languages?
We Were Here, with 22 languages against 12.





