Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6

Sea of Thieves vs Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is rated higher by critics (77 against 67), but players prefer Sea of Thieves. Sea of Thieves is the shorter one, at about 20 hours.

Side by side

Sea of Thieves compared with Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
MeasureSea of ThievesSherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Critics6777 (better)
Players89 (better)76
Released20182021
Time to beat20 h (better)40 h
GenresAdventure, Open WorldAdventure, Open World
Play withMultiplayer, Co-opSingle-player
PlatformsPC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox OnePC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S
DeveloperRare LtdFrogwares

Which one should you play?

Pick

Sea of Thieves

  • You have less time: about 20 hours against 40.
  • You want to play with a friend, since it has co-op and the other does not.
  • You play on Xbox One, where Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is not available.
Read about Sea of Thieves →

Pick

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One

  • You want the higher-rated game (77 against 67 from critics).
  • You want something to sink into: about 40 hours against 20.
  • You play on PS4, where Sea of Thieves is not available.
Read about Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One →
Compare other games

Quick verdicts

Critics prefer
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One77 v 67
Players prefer
Sea of Thieves89 v 76
Longer story
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One40 h v 20 h
Longer to 100%
Sea of Thieves200 h v 96 h
Bigger download
Sea of Thieves100 GB v 28 GB
Co-op
Sea of Thieves
Better for kids
Sea of Thieves
Steam Deck
Sea of ThievesVerified v Unsupported
More players now
Sea of Thieveson Steam
Newer
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One2021
More achievements
Sea of Thieves293 v 39
More languages
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One16 v 15

More about Sea of Thieves vs Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One

Scores

Which do critics rate higher, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One: 77 against 67.

Which do players prefer, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sea of Thieves: players rate it 89 against 76 out of 100.

Is Sea of Thieves better than Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

It depends who you ask: critics prefer Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, players prefer Sea of Thieves. Pick on genre and length instead.

Time and size

Which is longer, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, at about 40 hours for the main story against 20.

Which takes longer to 100%?

Sea of Thieves: about 200 hours to do everything, against 96.

Which is bigger to download, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sea of Thieves needs about 100 GB on PC, against 28 GB (from their Steam requirements).

Playing

Which has co-op, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sea of Thieves has co-op; Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One doesn't.

Which is better for kids, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sea of Thieves is rated for younger players (ESRB T, PEGI 12, against ESRB M, PEGI 16).

Is Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One first person?

Sea of Thieves is played in first person; Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One in third person.

Which runs better on Steam Deck?

Sea of Thieves (Verified), against Unsupported.

Which has more players right now?

Sea of Thieves: 2,985 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 23. Console players aren't counted.

Platforms

Can I play Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PS5?

Yes, both are on PS5.

Can I play Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on Xbox Series X/S?

Yes, both are on Xbox Series X/S.

Can I play Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PC?

Yes, both are on PC.

Which platforms have both Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S.

History

Which came out first, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sea of Thieves (2018) came out 3 years before Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One (2021).

Who made Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

Sea of Thieves is by Rare Ltd; Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is by Frogwares.

What do Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One have in common?

Both are adventure and open world games, and both are on PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S.

Extras

Which has more achievements?

Sea of Thieves, with 293 on Steam against 39.

Which has more DLC?

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, with 11 DLC items on Steam against 6.

Which supports more languages?

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, with 16 languages against 15.

Keep going