Sea of Thieves vs Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is rated higher by critics (77 against 67), but players prefer Sea of Thieves. Sea of Thieves is the shorter one, at about 20 hours.
Side by side
| Measure | Sea of Thieves | Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One |
|---|---|---|
| Critics | 67 | 77 (better) |
| Players | 89 (better) | 76 |
| Released | 2018 | 2021 |
| Time to beat | 20 h (better) | 40 h |
| Genres | Adventure, Open World | Adventure, Open World |
| Play with | Multiplayer, Co-op | Single-player |
| Platforms | PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One | PC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S |
| Developer | Rare Ltd | Frogwares |
Which one should you play?
Pick
Sea of Thieves
- You have less time: about 20 hours against 40.
- You want to play with a friend, since it has co-op and the other does not.
- You play on Xbox One, where Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is not available.
Pick
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
- You want the higher-rated game (77 against 67 from critics).
- You want something to sink into: about 40 hours against 20.
- You play on PS4, where Sea of Thieves is not available.
Quick verdicts
- Critics prefer
- Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One77 v 67
- Players prefer
- Sea of Thieves89 v 76
- Longer story
- Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One40 h v 20 h
- Longer to 100%
- Sea of Thieves200 h v 96 h
- Bigger download
- Sea of Thieves100 GB v 28 GB
- Co-op
- Sea of Thieves
- Better for kids
- Sea of Thieves
- Steam Deck
- Sea of ThievesVerified v Unsupported
- More players now
- Sea of Thieveson Steam
- Newer
- Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One2021
- More achievements
- Sea of Thieves293 v 39
- More languages
- Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One16 v 15
More about Sea of Thieves vs Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Scores
Which do critics rate higher, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One: 77 against 67.
Which do players prefer, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sea of Thieves: players rate it 89 against 76 out of 100.
Is Sea of Thieves better than Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
It depends who you ask: critics prefer Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, players prefer Sea of Thieves. Pick on genre and length instead.
Time and size
Which is longer, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, at about 40 hours for the main story against 20.
Which takes longer to 100%?
Sea of Thieves: about 200 hours to do everything, against 96.
Which is bigger to download, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sea of Thieves needs about 100 GB on PC, against 28 GB (from their Steam requirements).
Playing
Which has co-op, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sea of Thieves has co-op; Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One doesn't.
Which is better for kids, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sea of Thieves is rated for younger players (ESRB T, PEGI 12, against ESRB M, PEGI 16).
Is Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One first person?
Sea of Thieves is played in first person; Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One in third person.
Which runs better on Steam Deck?
Sea of Thieves (Verified), against Unsupported.
Which has more players right now?
Sea of Thieves: 2,985 people were playing on Steam on 12 November, against 23. Console players aren't counted.
Platforms
Can I play Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PS5?
Yes, both are on PS5.
Can I play Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on Xbox Series X/S?
Yes, both are on Xbox Series X/S.
Can I play Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PC?
Yes, both are on PC.
Which platforms have both Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S.
History
Which came out first, Sea of Thieves or Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sea of Thieves (2018) came out 3 years before Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One (2021).
Who made Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?
Sea of Thieves is by Rare Ltd; Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is by Frogwares.
What do Sea of Thieves and Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One have in common?
Both are adventure and open world games, and both are on PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S.
Extras
Which has more achievements?
Sea of Thieves, with 293 on Steam against 39.
Which has more DLC?
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, with 11 DLC items on Steam against 6.
Which supports more languages?
Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, with 16 languages against 15.

