XBOX · RANKED GUIDE
Best Xbox RPGs
15 Xbox RPGs out now have a critic score, and Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders leads them with a 81. Role-playing games where your choices and your build shape the story. The list spans 2002 to 2006, and the typical game takes about 45 hours to finish. 5 are Xbox exclusives.
- ranked
- 15
- avg top-10 critics
- 77
- typical length
- 45h
The top three
1Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders2004 · Action RPG / Strategy81 critics93 players
2Tony Hawk's Underground2003 · Racing / RPG90 critics80 players
3X-Men Legends II: Rise of Apocalypse2005 · Action RPG / Fantasy84 critics71 players
- 4
Shenmue II2002 · RPG / Fantasy · 20h80 - 5
The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age2004 · RPG / Strategy · 45h76 - 6
Sudeki2004 · RPG / Fantasy · 45h72 - 7
Castlevania: Curse of Darkness2005 · Action RPG / Horror · 40h74 - 8
Dungeons & Dragons: Heroes2003 · Action RPG / Fantasy · 40h72 - 9
Forgotten Realms: Demon Stone2004 · RPG / Fantasy · 45h71 - 10
The Bard's Tale2004 · RPG / Fantasy · 45h70 - 11
ToeJam & Earl III: Mission to Earth2002 · Platformer / RPG · 45h71 - 12
Justice League Heroes2006 · RPG · 45h68 - 13
Knights of the Temple II2005 · Action RPG / Fantasy · 40h53 - 14
NightCaster II: Equinox2002 · RPG · 45h46 - 15
Black Stone: Magic & Steel2003 · RPG / Fantasy · 45h44
Quick answers
What is the best Xbox RPG?
By our blend of critic scores (75%) and player scores (25%), it is Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders (81 from critics, 93/100 from players). The next four are Tony Hawk's Underground, X-Men Legends II: Rise of Apocalypse, Shenmue II and The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age.
How long are these games?
The middle game in this list takes about 45 hours to beat. The shortest takes about 20 hours.
Where do these scores come from?
Critic scores are Metacritic's Xbox scores where we have them. Player scores come from store ratings or reviews with at least 10 ratings. Only games that are out and have a critic score are ranked.
More about Best Xbox RPGs
More answers
What are the most popular Xbox RPGs?
The Bard's Tale, Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders, Sudeki, Tony Hawk's Underground and Shenmue II.
What are the newest Xbox RPGs?
Justice League Heroes (2006), Knights of the Temple II (2005), Castlevania: Curse of Darkness (2005) and X-Men Legends II: Rise of Apocalypse (2005).
What are the best Xbox RPGs for beginners?
Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders, Tony Hawk's Underground, X-Men Legends II: Rise of Apocalypse and Shenmue II.
Which Xbox RPGs have co-op?
Dungeons & Dragons: Heroes and Justice League Heroes.
Which Xbox RPGs are console exclusives?
Not on the other consoles (some are also on PC): Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders, Sudeki, ToeJam & Earl III: Mission to Earth and NightCaster II: Equinox.
What are the longest Xbox RPGs?
The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age (about 45 hours), Sudeki (about 45 hours) and Forgotten Realms: Demon Stone (about 45 hours).
How many Xbox RPGs are there?
15 with a critic score in our catalogue.
Keep going
Compare
Kingdom Under Fire: The Crusaders vs Tony Hawk's Underground
The top two, side by side: scores, length, modes and which suits you.
Go →Not sure?
Find a Xbox game for you
Four quick questions about your mood and time, then five picks.
Go →More Xbox
Best Xbox shooters
First- and third-person shooters, from tight campaigns to online arenas.
Go →