The short answer
By Metacritic, the best crime games are Grand Theft Auto IV (98), Grand Theft Auto V (97), Vice City (95), L.A. Noire (89), Yakuza 0 and Kiwami 2 (85), Judgment (80), Mafia: Definitive Edition (78) and Mafia II (77). Players rate Vice City highest.
The best crime game, by critics, is Grand Theft Auto IV, with a Metacritic score of 98, ahead of Grand Theft Auto V at 97 and Vice City at 95. Players, in our own data, rate Vice City highest of the nine. All nine below are story-led crime games with a city to explore, and we left out any game centred on selling drugs.
01How we ranked them
- Ranked by
- Metacritic
- Critic score, linked per game
- Tie-break
- Player ratings
- From our own data, not quoted
- Games
- 9
- Ad-safe picks only
Order is Metacritic first. Where two games tie, our player ratings decide, which is why Yakuza 0 sits above Kiwami 2. For heists, vehicle chases and open-world chaos with a lighter tone, see games like GTA 5, which covers Saints Row, Sleeping Dogs, Watch Dogs 2 and Payday 2. We do not repeat them here.
Grand Theft Auto IV artworkSourcesMetacritic
021 to 3: Rockstar's three great cities

2008 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto IV1. The most serious Grand Theft Auto. Niko Bellic arrives in Liberty City chasing a better life and finds crime is the only available work. It is slower and heavier than its successor, and its Metacritic 98 reflects how much critics admired that weight.
Grand Theft Auto V artwork
2013 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto V2. Three leads, one heist-driven campaign. Switching between Michael, Franklin and Trevor keeps the pace up, and its planned jobs are why heist games are still compared with it. The satire of Los Santos is the other half of the appeal.
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City artwork
2002 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City3. The 1980s Miami-inspired original, and the one players rate highest in our data. It is short, funny and full of period music. It is also the game that first put Vice City on the map, before GTA 6 returns there.
SourcesMetacritic · Metacritic
034 to 6: the detective and the Japanese underworld
L.A. Noire artwork
2011 · Action-Adventure
L.A. Noire4. The odd one on this list: you are a 1947 Los Angeles detective, so you gather clues and interrogate suspects more than you shoot. Slow if you want chaos, rewarding if you like working out who is lying.
Yakuza 0 artwork
2015 · Action-Adventure
Yakuza 05. A 1988 prequel set in Kamurocho and Sotenbori, with two leads, Kiryu and Majima. Streets are compact rather than huge, and its brawling is the draw, with a lot of side stories and mini-games. A good place to start the series.
Yakuza Kiwami 2 artwork
2017 · RPG
Yakuza Kiwami 26. A 2017 remake of the second game, tied with Yakuza 0 on score but rated slightly lower by players. It is a tighter, more serious Kiryu story. Newcomers should still start with the prequel.
SourcesMetacritic · Metacritic · Metacritic
047 to 9: a lawyer, and two gangster families
Judgment artwork
2018 · Action-Adventure
Judgment7. Takayuki Yagami is a former lawyer turned detective in the same Kamurocho streets as Yakuza. It mixes tailing suspects and investigation with fast fights, and is a good pick if you liked L.A. Noire's mystery.
Mafia: Definitive Edition artwork
2020 · Action-Adventure
Mafia: Definitive Edition8. A 2020 remake of a 1930s gangster story, told in flashback by Tommy Angelo. Driving is deliberate and the story is short, a few evenings for most. Choose it for plot over freedom.
Mafia II artwork
2010 · Action-Adventure
Mafia II9. Vito Scaletta's rise through the families of 1940s and 50s Empire Bay. It is a linear story, not a sandbox, so do not expect side jobs to wander off to. Its period cars and music carry it.
SourcesMetacritic · Metacritic · Metacritic
05Where critics and players disagree
Mafia III artworkThe biggest gap in our data is at the top. Critics put Grand Theft Auto IV first, but players rate Vice City, from 2002, higher than any other game here. Our guess, and it is only a guess, is that a short, funny game ages better in memory than a long, grim one.
- Critics' top pick
- GTA IV
- Metacritic 98
- Players' top pick
- Vice City
- Highest in our data
- Lowest Mafia
- Mafia III
- Metacritic 62
At the bottom, Mafia III, with a Metacritic 62, did not make the nine. It is the lowest-scoring Mafia game in our data, and we chose games that are good to play, not just good to discuss.
One more thing we left out on purpose: any crime game built around selling drugs. We keep this site safe for family-friendly ads, and plenty of games about the crime world do not need that. Every game here still carries a mature rating, so check your region's age rating first. If you are a parent, our age-band pages list what suits younger players, and our guide to games like GTA for kids and teens covers the milder end.
Which should you play first? If GTA 6 is the reason you are here, start with Vice City, because Leonida's biggest city is Vice City, and our Rockstar ranking shows how its siblings score. If you want a story that is not a Grand Theft Auto, pick L.A. Noire or Yakuza 0.
Quick answers
What is the best crime game of all time?
By Metacritic, Grand Theft Auto IV, at 98, narrowly ahead of Grand Theft Auto V at 97. Players in our data rate Vice City highest.
What is the best crime game for a story?
L.A. Noire if you want a detective story, Yakuza 0 for a long character drama, and Mafia: Definitive Edition for a short, linear one.
Are Yakuza games suitable for kids?
No. They carry mature ratings for strong violence and adult themes. Check the rating in your region before buying.
Keep going
SourcesMetacritic
Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.




