The short answer
Grand Theft Auto IV is Rockstar's best-reviewed game, with a Metacritic score of 98. GTA III, GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 follow on 97. Red Dead Redemption, Vice City and San Andreas score 95. All scores as of 12 November 2026.
Grand Theft Auto IV is Rockstar's best-reviewed game: 98 on Metacritic. GTA III, GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 follow on 97, then Red Dead Redemption, Vice City and San Andreas on 95 (scores from our catalogue, as of 12 November).
Twelve games are ranked below, in order of score, each with a reason it sits where it does. Five more with lower scores follow, then our method. GTA 6, out on 19 November, has no score yet.
- 98
- GTA IV
- Rockstar's top score
- 97
- Three games
- GTA III, GTA V, RDR2
- 95
- Three games
- RDR, Vice City, San Andreas
- 17
- Games ranked
- With a Metacritic score
SourcesMetacritic
01Rockstar's 12 best-reviewed games
Ties are ordered by release date, earliest first.

2008 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto IV98. Rockstar North's 2008 game is the top of the list on critics' scores, and it earned it with a smaller, more serious Liberty City than San Andreas's sprawl. Niko Bellic's story is the reason people still argue for it.

2001 · Action-Adventure
Grand Theft Auto III97. The 2001 game that turned the series into a 3D city. It is on this list for what it started; most of what came after copied its structure.

2013 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto V97. Three playable leads and a Los Santos with enough to do that people are still playing it in 2026. It is the previous game GTA 6 has to match.

2018 · Open World
Red Dead Redemption 297. The slowest game on the list, and a deliberate choice: the gang camp, the horse bond and the pace of travel are the point. Brilliant if you like patient play, tedious if you do not.

2010 · Action-Adventure
Red Dead Redemption95. The 2010 Western from Rockstar San Diego that proved the studio could do more than cities. It matches Vice City's score of 95.

2002 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City95. A 1980s Miami-style city with a soundtrack as the main attraction. GTA 6 returns here, so this is the game to read up on first.

2004 · Open World
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas95. A state, not a city: three cities and the countryside between them. It is the biggest of the older games by area.

2009 · Crime
Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars93. The surprise at number 8: a DS game, played from above, that outscores L.A. Noire and both Max Payne sequels.

2011 · Action-Adventure
L.A. Noire89. Developed by Team Bondi and published by Rockstar, so it is here as a publishing credit. A detective game built on questioning suspects, not on shooting.

2003 · Shooter
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne86. Developed by Remedy and published by Rockstar, again a publishing credit. A short, tightly built shooter with slow-motion dives, which is why people recommend it to this day.

2012 · Shooter
Max Payne 386 (Xbox 360). The one Rockstar Studios made itself, moving the series from New York noir to Brazil. Same score as the second game, a very different feel.

2006 · Action-Adventure
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories86 (PSP). A prequel to Vice City made for a handheld, and a reminder that the series travelled well beyond consoles.
02The weaker scores
The weaker scores
Three of the five, from Rockstar's other studios.
Five more games have a score, all under 86. Each links to its page:
- The Warriors, 85 (Xbox): a brawler from Rockstar Toronto, based on the 1979 gang film, and the best-scored of the games below.
- Midnight Club II, 81 (PC): Rockstar San Diego's street-racing series, and the only Midnight Club with a score in our data.
- Manhunt, 75 (PC): a stealth game from Rockstar North that was divisive. We describe its content only in general terms: it carries a strong violence rating.
- Bully, 72 (PC): a school-set game from Rockstar Vancouver. The 72 is the PC score in our data.
- Grand Theft Auto 2, 70 (PS1): the lowest score in the catalogue.
Scores here follow the platform Metacritic names in our data, so a PC score and a console score for the same game can differ. The Warriors and Red Dead Redemption have no usable Metacritic link in our data, so they link to our pages only.
03How did we rank them?
- 12
- Ranked
- Best-reviewed Rockstar games
- 5
- Lower scores
- All under 86
- 17
- With a score
- In our catalogue
- Source: the Metacritic score attached to each game in our catalogue (the 'critic' field), checked 12 November 2026. We link each score to its Metacritic page where our data has one.
- Included: games where our data lists Rockstar (or one of its studios) as developer or publisher. That covers games Rockstar published but did not build, such as L.A. Noire and Max Payne 2. We say which in the entry.
- Left out: games with no score in our data (Grand Theft Auto, Liberty City Stories, Manhunt 2, Midnight Club 3 and Los Angeles, and others), the original Max Payne (not listed under Rockstar in our data), and GTA Advance, whose Metacritic link in our data we could not match to the right page.
- Ties: ordered by release date. We did not use player scores or sales.
The full list, with where to play each, is on our Rockstar Games studio page. Waiting for GTA 6? See our games like GTA 6 list.
Play Next · 10 seconds
Not sure which Rockstar game to play next?
Pick a mood and the time you have, and we will suggest one.
I want…
I have…
Quick answers
What is Rockstar's highest-rated game?
Grand Theft Auto IV, with a Metacritic score of 98. GTA III, GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 follow on 97.
Is Red Dead Redemption 2 better than GTA 5?
Critics rate them the same: both are 97 on Metacritic in our data. The difference is pace. RDR2 is slower and GTA V is more varied.
What is Rockstar's lowest-rated game?
Among the games with a score in our data, Grand Theft Auto 2 at 70.
What will GTA 6 score?
It has no score yet. GTA 6 launches on 19 November 2026, and we will not guess.
Keep going
Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.









