Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6
Analysis & OpinionTime-sensitive

What GTA 6 needs for a 95 Metacritic: only 43 of 6,797 games got there

Only 43 of the 6,797 scored games in our catalogue reach 95. Here is what GTA 6 must do to join them, and how Rockstar's record looks.

CEConsolyte Editors · 12 November 2026 · 4 min read

Image: Lucia Caminos in a Vice City gym · Rockstar Games

The short answer

GTA 6 needs to match Rockstar's record: GTA IV 98, GTA V 97, Red Dead Redemption 2 97. A 95 is rare, 43 of 6,797 scored games in our data. That is our reading: nobody has reviewed GTA 6 yet, and reviews are reported for 18 November.

To score 95 or higher, GTA 6 has to do what Rockstar's last three big games did: be a technical showpiece and a story people talk about. Grand Theft Auto IV scored 98, GTA V 97 and Red Dead Redemption 2 97 on Metacritic. A 95 is rare, though: only 43 of the 6,797 scored games in our catalogue reach it.

Everything about what reviewers will say is our reading, and we label it as such. Nobody outside Rockstar has published a review. Reviews are reported to go live on 18 November, a day before launch, and we explain that in our review embargo guide.

43
Games at 95 or higher
Of 6,797 scored
319
Games at 90 or higher
Of 6,797 scored
98
GTA IV, Rockstar's best
Metacritic
18 Nov
Reported review day
Not confirmed

01How rare is a 95 on Metacritic?

Rockstar's three biggest scores

Metacritic, from our catalogue. This is the bar GTA 6 is measured against.

Very. 319 reach 90 and 43 reach 95, which is under one per cent.

Rockstar owns a lot of that shelf. Grand Theft Auto IV has 98, GTA V 97, Red Dead Redemption 2 97, and GTA III 97. Vice City has 95 and San Andreas 95.

The company is exclusive. Other 97s in our data include Breath of the Wild and Super Mario Odyssey, and Baldur's Gate 3 and Tears of the Kingdom sit at 96.

Sources98 · 97 · 97 · 97 · 95 · 95 · Breath of the Wild · Super Mario Odyssey

02What did Rockstar's top-scoring games do right?

GTA 6, GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2 maps at the same scale
The three maps at the same scale. Rockstar's top scorers were also its biggest worlds

Each one won critics in a different way, and that is useful for GTA 6. GTA IV was praised for a grounded Liberty City and a serious story about Niko Bellic. GTA V put three playable leads in one heist-driven story. Red Dead Redemption 2 was praised for a world that reacted to you and a slow, character-led plot.

The pattern is simple. Each game was the most detailed open world of its day, and each had at least one lead people remembered. We think GTA 6 needs both, and the two-lead story is its best chance at the second.

03What will reviewers judge in GTA 6?

The slim jim or smash window prompts when stealing a car in GTA 6
Systems detail like the car-theft prompt is what reviewers notice first. A scene from Rockstar's Extended Look.

Our reading: five things decide a Rockstar score. The first is the world, meaning how alive and reactive Leonida feels once you leave the main road. The second is the story and the two leads, Jason and Lucia.

The third is mission design, which reviewers punish quickly if it becomes repetitive. The fourth is technical state: bugs, loading and frame rate. The fifth is whether the game earns its length, because a 40-hour story that drags will cost points.

Jason and Lucia sitting together on a pickup on a hill overlooking Vice City at sunset
Jason and Lucia overlooking Vice City. Reviewers will judge whether the two-lead story lands. Rockstar Games.

Story matters more for Rockstar than for most studios. Red Dead Redemption 2's 97 rested heavily on Arthur Morgan, and GTA IV's 98 on Niko Bellic. If GTA 6 builds a pair of leads people care about, it has the best route to a 95.

04Could the technical side hold it back?

It is the biggest open question. Rockstar confirmed on 10 November that GTA 6 is targeting 30 frames per second on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S. On PS5 Pro it uses PSSR upscaling and ray-traced shadows.

Most critics accepted 30fps in Red Dead Redemption 2 without losing a point. A 30fps target in 2026 is more contentious, so frame pacing and bugs matter more than the number. See our 60fps and PS5 Pro guide for the details.

  • ConfirmedGTA 6 targets 30fps on PS5 and Xbox Series X|SRockstar, 10 November, reported by GamingBible. A 60fps mode is not explicitly ruled out.
  • RumourGTA 6 will score 95 or higherNobody has reviewed it. Any score before the embargo lifts is a guess.
  • ReportedReviews go live on 18 NovemberNateTheHate, verified by Insider Gaming. Rockstar has not announced it.

Sourcesconfirmed on 10 November

05What could stop GTA 6 reaching 95?

Jason and Lucia fleeing on a motorbike from a police car and a helicopter in GTA 6
The wanted system in action. Reviewers will test whether chases stay fun after hours. Rockstar Games.

Our reading: three things. First, repetition, because open-world games with more things to do can feel padded. Second, a single-player-only launch: Rockstar has announced no online mode for launch, and some critics may mark that down.

Third, the weight of 13 years of expectation. A 90 would be a strong score for almost any game, yet readers will call it a disappointment if GTA 6 does not match GTA V. Scores are also not the same as sales: GTA V's 97 came with record sales, and GTA 6 will probably sell whatever the score.

06When will we know?

If the report holds, scores arrive on 18 November and Metacritic starts counting within hours. Our embargo guide explains the time-of-day uncertainty, and we will update this page as soon as Rockstar or Metacritic says more. Remember that the first number you see may be built on a few dozen reviews.

When scores arrive, read two or three full reviews and not only the average. The first hours of a Metacritic page can move by a point or two as more outlets publish.

A last word on the video claim that GTA 6 might disappoint. There is no evidence for it and none against it, because no review exists yet. The honest position is to wait for the scores, read a few full reviews, and judge it by what you enjoy rather than by a number.

Quick answers

What is the highest-scoring Rockstar game on Metacritic?

Grand Theft Auto IV, at 98. Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption 2 both have 97, per our catalogue.

How many games score 95 or higher?

43 of the 6,797 games with a critic score in our catalogue, which is under one per cent.

When will GTA 6 reviews come out?

Reported for 18 November 2026, one day before launch. Rockstar has not confirmed it.

Will GTA 6 score higher than GTA V?

Nobody knows yet. GTA V scored 97. Anything we say before reviews is our reading, not a fact.

Keep going

Image credits (1)
  • GTA 6, GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2 maps at the same scale: YANIS community map, Rockstar Games

Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.

Read next · 7 minEvery Rockstar game ranked by critics: GTA IV leads on 98GTA IV tops Rockstar's catalogue on 98, with GTA III, GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 on 97. Here are 12 games ranked by Metacritic, then the weaker ones, with our method.

Games in this article

Keep reading