The short answer
By our weighted blend of critic and player scores, the best game of all time is Ocarina of Time, followed by Baldur's Gate 3, Half-Life 2, Portal 2 and Half-Life. The blend is 75% critics and 25% players, pulled towards 70 until reviews back each score.
The best game of all time, by our weighted data, is The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Baldur's Gate 3, Half-Life 2, Portal 2 and Half-Life follow. The ranking blends critic scores and player ratings from our catalogue, and below we explain exactly how.
No list can settle this for everyone, and ours is a method, not a verdict. It does answer a fair question: which games do both critics and players agree on? Checked 12 November 2026.
01How do we rank the best games ever?
Before launch: your checklist
- 1Take both scoresCritic scores (Metacritic-style) count for 75%. Player ratings count for 25%.
- 2Pull each towards 70A score is adjusted towards an ordinary 70 until enough reviews back it up, the way IMDb ranks its top films. One 98 from a handful of critics cannot beat a 94 from hundreds.
- 3Require real player numbersA game needs at least 500 player ratings. That removes NFL 2K1, which has a Metacritic 97 but no player ratings, and would otherwise sit tenth.
- 4Limit each seriesNo more than three games per series, and remasters count with their originals.
One more rule: we quote a Metacritic score only where our catalogue has a link to it. Ocarina of Time tops our data but has no linked page, so we leave its number out.
- 6,797
- Games with a critic score
- In our catalogue
- 75/25
- Critics to players
- The blend
- 500
- Minimum player ratings
- To be ranked
- 3
- Max games per series
- Remasters count as originals
02The top five: which games lead?

1998 · Action-Adventure
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time1. The 1998 game that taught 3D adventures to lock on to an enemy and has just been remade for Switch 2. It tops our blend narrowly. We have no linked Metacritic page, so no number, but its critic score is the highest in our data.

2023 · RPG
Baldur's Gate 32. A role-playing game built on choice: talk, sneak, fight or break the plan entirely and the world answers. Metacritic 96, with the most player ratings of any game in the top five.

2004 · Shooter
Half-Life 23. Physics as a puzzle: the gravity gun turns a saw blade and a radiator into tools. Metacritic 96. It shaped how shooters tell a story without cutscenes.

2011 · Puzzle
Portal 24. A puzzle game with a cast of three voices and a joke in every corridor. Metacritic 95. Few games are this funny and this clever together.

1998 · Shooter
Half-Life5. A 1998 shooter that never cuts away from the player's eyes. Metacritic 96. It is ranked by critics and players for the same reason: nobody had paced a shooter this well before.
03Ranks 6 to 10: the open worlds and the strange one

2011 · Action-Adventure
Batman: Arkham City6. A city-sized sandbox for a superhero, with a combat system that rewards rhythm. Metacritic 96. Still one of the best licensed games made.

2017 · Open World
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild7. Climb anything, glide anywhere, solve a shrine your way. Metacritic 97. It changed how open worlds are built, and its sequel is further down.

2018 · Open World
Red Dead Redemption 28. A slow, detailed Western where the world reacts to how you treat it. Metacritic 97. It ties Grand Theft Auto V at 97, and is Rockstar's best-reviewed open world since.

2012 · Adventure
The House in Fata Morgana9. The surprise on the list: a gothic mystery visual novel, told in reverse, with no combat at all. Metacritic 96. A small game with a devoted audience.

2007 · Shooter
BioShock10. An underwater city whose story is told through its architecture. Metacritic 96. Its 'would you kindly' twist is still one of gaming's best-known reveals.
04Ranks 11 to 15: platforming, deck-building and a Norse reboot

2010 · Platformer
Super Mario Galaxy 211. Pure platforming invention, with a new idea every few minutes. Metacritic 98, the highest linked critic score on this list, though its smaller player count holds the blend back.

2025 · Roguelike
Hades II12. A fast, mythic action game where each death moves the story on. Metacritic 94. It sits above its predecessor in our data.

2018 · Action-Adventure
God of War (2018)13. Kratos as a tired father with an axe, in a single unbroken camera shot. Metacritic 94. The restart that gave a long-running series a new heart.

2023 · Roguelike
Cobalt Core14. A deck-building roguelike on a spaceship, where cards are also your crew. Metacritic 94. The least-known high scorer here, and a good gamble.

2023 · Open World
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom15. The sequel adds building and a sky of islands to Breath of the Wild's map. Metacritic 96. Our data puts it just below the game it follows.
05Ranks 16 to 20: the veterans

2022 · Action-Adventure
God of War Ragnarök16. A story-driven sequel that keeps the fighting from the first game and widens the world. Metacritic 94, with a very large player base.

1996 · Shooter
Quake17. A 1996 shooter that helped define fast 3D movement and online play. Metacritic 94. Its modding scene shaped much of what followed.

2017 · Platformer
Super Mario Odyssey18. Throw a cap onto an enemy and you become it. Metacritic 97. The game that put the idea of capturing into a Mario platformer.

2020 · Roguelike
Hades19. The roguelike that made repeating a run feel like progress. Metacritic 93. Players rate it among the very best in our data.

2020 · Shooter
Half-Life: Alyx20. A virtual reality prequel that treats your hands as the controls. Metacritic 93. It is the series' third entry on the list, which is the limit under our rule.
06Which games just missed the top 20?
Super Mario Galaxy, The Last of Us and Persona 5 sit close behind in our data. They missed by small margins in the blend. The rankings page shows where they land.
Just outside the top 20
Close behind in our blend.
A note on fairness: older games have had longer to gather ratings, and blends favour them. A new game such as Resident Evil Requiem, with 93, has had less time to gather ratings, so it ranks lower than its score alone would suggest.
Play Next · 10 seconds
Not sure which of the 20 to play?
Tell us your mood and how long you have. One game, no scrolling.
I want…
I have…
Quick answers
What is the best game of all time?
By our weighted blend of critic and player scores, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Baldur's Gate 3 and Half-Life 2 are next.
How does Consolyte rank games?
75% critic score and 25% player rating, each pulled towards 70 until enough reviews back it up. Games need at least 500 player ratings.
Is Red Dead Redemption 2 in the top 10?
Yes, eighth in our blend, with a Metacritic score of 97.
Why is a lower-scored game ranked above a higher-scored one?
Because players count for a quarter, and games with more reviews keep more of their score. Super Mario Galaxy 2 has a 98 but fewer player ratings.
Keep going
Sources93
Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.







