Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6
Lists & Rankings

Fans vs critics: games players rate far higher (Hello Neighbor) and far lower (Tekken 8)

Hello Neighbor has a Metacritic score of 38 and an 8.5 from players. Tekken 8 has 91 and a 5.9. Nine games where fans and critics disagree most, and how we measured it.

CDConsolyte Data · 12 November 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer

In our data the biggest gaps are Hello Neighbor, Five Nights at Freddy's 4 and Rain World, which players rate far above critics, and Tekken 8, Marvel Tokon and Planet Zoo 2, which players rate far below them. Only real player ratings, with at least 2,000 votes, count.

Players rate Hello Neighbor, Five Nights at Freddy's 4 and Rain World far above their critic scores, and they rate Tekken 8, Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls and Planet Zoo 2 far below theirs. Hello Neighbor has a Metacritic score of 38 and an 8.5 out of 10 from players. Tekken 8 has 91 and a 5.9.

Below are nine of the widest gaps in our catalogue, with the method and the likely reasons. The reasons are our reading unless a source is linked.

01How do we measure the gap between fans and critics?

1,468
games with a Metacritic page, real player ratings and at least 2,000 votes
2,000
minimum player votes
10×
player score out of 10, scaled to 100
12 Nov
data checked

For each game we take the Metacritic score (out of 100) and the player score (out of 10) and multiply the player score by ten. The gap is the difference. We only use games where our data marks the player rating as real not estimated, and that have at least 2,000 votes.

Most of the player scores come from Steam. Where Metacritic's score is for the PC version we compare it with the Steam crowd. Where it is for a console we say so, because a PC crowd and a console critic are not judging the same release. We also skipped games carrying adult-content labels from the rating boards, and games where Metacritic's score came from a handheld port.

02Which games do players love far more than critics?

Key art for Hello NeighborCover art for Hello Neighbor
Hello Neighbor, the stealth game with the largest gap on this list. Cover art via the game page.

Hello Neighbor. Metacritic 38 (PC), players 8.5 from 11,197 ratings, a gap of 47 points. A stealth game rated E10+ in which you sneak into a neighbour's house. Critics were unimpressed. Our reading is that players value the idea, and the stories and videos people share about it, more than the polish.

Key art for Five Nights at Freddy's 4Cover art for Five Nights at Freddy's 4
Five Nights at Freddy's 4. Cover art via the game page.

Five Nights at Freddy's 4. Metacritic 51 (PC), players 9.3 from 8,914 ratings, a gap of 42. A horror game rated T. Players who like the series judge each entry against its own fans, not against other games.

Key art for Rain WorldCover art for Rain World
Rain World, a survival platformer. Cover art via the game page.

Rain World. Metacritic 66 (PC), players 9.5 from 31,094 ratings, a gap of 29. You are a slugcat in an ecosystem that does not care about you, and it is rated E10+. Our reading: a game that is hard to love at first is easy to love once it clicks, and fans rate it after it has.

Two more where fans win

Skater XL has Metacritic 56 against players 8.4; Poly Bridge 2 has 69 against 9.6.

Skater XL (Metacritic 56, PC) has 12,730 player ratings and a gap of 28. Poly Bridge 2 (Metacritic 69) has 4,530 and a gap of 27. Both are games for a niche: a skating sim and a bridge-building puzzler. Niche games tend to be rated by the people who wanted them.

SourcesMetacritic 38 · Metacritic 51 · Metacritic 66 · Metacritic 56 · Metacritic 69

03Which games do players rate far lower than critics?

Key art for Tekken 8Cover art for Tekken 8
Tekken 8, one of the two biggest negative gaps on this list. Cover art via the game page.

Tekken 8. Metacritic 91 (PC), players 5.9 from 27,732 ratings, a gap of -32. Critics praised the fighting; Steam players complained, as reported at the time, about in-game purchases. A fighting game rated T.

Key art for Marvel Tokon: Fighting SoulsCover art for Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls
Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls. Cover art via the game page.

Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls. Metacritic 83 (PC), players 4.8 from 4,213 ratings, a gap of -35. Reports cite poor PC performance, no Linux or Steam Deck support and a PlayStation account requirement, per GamesRadar. These are about the release, not the fighting.

Key art for Planet Zoo 2Cover art for Planet Zoo 2
Planet Zoo 2, released in October 2026. Cover art via the game page.

Planet Zoo 2. Metacritic 84 (PC), players 6.2 from 3,536 ratings, a gap of -22. Steam players report bugs, crashes and missing species, according to GameDaily. It is the newest game here, so patches could close the gap.

Cover art for Battlefield 2042

2021 · Shooter

Battlefield 2042

Metacritic 68 (PC), players 4.7 from 106,590 ratings, a gap of -21. The biggest crowd on the list, and one of the lowest scores. Rated M. Its player score reflects, in our reading, how the game launched in 2021 more than how it plays today.

Critic Metacritic684.7 players

SourcesMetacritic 91 · Metacritic 83 · GamesRadar · Metacritic 84 · GameDaily · Metacritic 68

04What explains the gaps?

Three patterns repeat. Critics review a game once, at launch, and fans rate it for years. Fans of a niche rate the games they chose, and critics rate whatever they are given. Last, a store score can fall because of a price, a login rule or a bug, none of which a review of the game itself covers.

There is also a size effect. A game with 100,000 ratings, like Battlefield 2042, has a very stable player score. A game with 2,000 ratings can swing by a point or more with a few busy weeks, which is why we set a floor.

Our advice is simple. If critics and players agree, you can trust the number. If they split, read why. A game players love and critics do not may be exactly right for you, and a game critics love and players do not may have a fixable problem. Check the reasons in the game page, then decide.

None of this makes either side wrong. A critic score tells you how a game reads on day one. A player score tells you how it holds up in the hands of people who bought it. Use both.

Quick answers

Which game do players rate higher than critics the most?

In our data, Hello Neighbor: Metacritic 38 against a player score of 8.5 out of 10, a gap of 47 points.

Which game do players rate lower than critics the most?

Among well-known recent games, Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls (Metacritic 83, players 4.8) and Tekken 8 (91 against 5.9).

How do you count player ratings?

Only where our data marks them as real ratings, with at least 2,000 votes. The score out of 10 is multiplied by ten to compare it with Metacritic.

Can a player score change?

Yes. Patches and price changes move it, which is why we date the data. Planet Zoo 2 is the likeliest to shift.

Keep going

Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.

Read next · 7 minEvery Rockstar game ranked by critics: GTA IV leads on 98GTA IV tops Rockstar's catalogue on 98, with GTA III, GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 on 97. Here are 12 games ranked by Metacritic, then the weaker ones, with our method.

Games in this article

Keep reading