Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6
Lists & RankingsTime-sensitive

Best horror games ranked: Silent Hill 2 and Alan Wake 2, plus the best of 2026

Thirteen horror games ranked by our data: eight of all time and five from 2026, chosen for atmosphere and tension rather than graphic violence.

CDConsolyte Data · 12 November 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer

The best horror games by our data are Silent Hill 2 (2024), Alan Wake 2, Alien: Isolation and SOMA, with Resident Evil Requiem the best of 2026. We ranked atmosphere and tension above graphic violence, so every pick can be described in general terms.

The best horror games, by our data, are Silent Hill 2 (2024), Alan Wake 2, Alien: Isolation and SOMA. The best of 2026 so far is Resident Evil Requiem. This list has eight all-time picks and five from this year.

The horror games that lead our list

Eight of all time, five from 2026

How we chose: we took every game tagged Horror in our catalogue, ranked by Metacritic score and player ratings, and then removed games whose main appeal is graphic violence. What is left leans on atmosphere, sound, tension and story. That is a judgement call, and it means some famous horror games are not here. Scores below link to Metacritic where our data has a page.

01The best horror games of all time, by atmosphere

Key art for Silent Hill 2 (2024)Silent Hill 2 (2024) artwork
1. Silent Hill 2 (2024), 87. The remake of a classic about grief and a fog-covered town. Dread comes from mood and story more than from shocks. PC and PS5.

It is a long, slow game, and it is the one we would start with. Wait for a quiet evening, turn the lights down and let the fog do the work.

Key art for Alan Wake 2Alan Wake 2 artwork
2. Alan Wake 2, 89. A writer, an FBI agent and a story that bends reality. It is tense and strange, and more of a puzzle than a fight. PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S.
Key art for Alien: IsolationAlien: Isolation artwork
3. Alien: Isolation, 81. One creature, one huge station, and you with almost nothing. It is the best case in games for hiding as a way to play. Many platforms, including Switch.

It rewards patience. Learn the station, listen for the creature and plan your route, and the tension builds without a single loud moment.

Key art for SOMASOMA artwork
4. SOMA, 84. Set under the sea, and more unsettling than frightening. Its question about what makes you, you, is the real scare. PC, PS4, Xbox One and Switch.

If you prefer ideas to jump scares, play this first. It is a horror game you will still be thinking about a week later.

Key art for SignalisSignalis artwork
5. Signalis. A sci-fi survival horror with a retro look and a cold, melancholy mood. Short, strange and stylish. PC, PS4, Xbox One and Switch.

Not sure you want to be scared for ten hours? The next three are gentler, and they are a good way into the genre.

Key art for Little Nightmares IILittle Nightmares II artwork
6. Little Nightmares II, 82. A dark fable about a small child and large, odd adults. More creepy than cruel, with clever platform puzzles. PC, PlayStation, Xbox and Switch.
Key art for DredgeDredge artwork
7. Dredge. Fish by day, and be careful out on the water at night. The fear is slow and creeping, and the fishing is genuinely cosy. PC, consoles and Switch.
Key art for Until DawnUntil Dawn artwork
8. Until Dawn, 79. A cinematic story where your choices decide who makes it through the night. Best with a friend on the sofa. PC and PS4.

Sources87 · 89 · 81 · 84 · 82 · 79

02The best horror games of 2026

Five 2026 games stand out in our data. We have tied each to its Metacritic page where we have one, and kept the descriptions short because many are new.

Key art for Resident Evil RequiemResident Evil Requiem artwork
1. Resident Evil Requiem, 93. The top-scoring horror game of 2026 in our data, and the most action-led pick on this page. It earns its place on tension and pacing. PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2.
Key art for Silver PinesSilver Pines artwork
2. Silver Pines, 85. Listed in our data as a puzzle and survival horror, with a score of 85 and very high player ratings. A small game with big word of mouth. PC, consoles and Switch.

Check the platform on the store page before buying, as the game is out on several consoles and PC, and dates can differ.

Key art for ReanimalReanimal artwork
3. Reanimal, 83. A dreamlike, misty puzzle-horror with huge, strange creatures in the distance. Its look is built on mood. PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2.
Key art for Silent Hill: TownfallSilent Hill: Townfall artwork
4. Silent Hill: Townfall, 80. A new first-person Silent Hill about a small town and its puzzles. It is a quieter take on the series. PC and PS5.
Key art for Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly RemakeFatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake artwork
5. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake, 78. A remake of a cult favourite where the camera is your tool for facing ghosts. Spooky rather than violent. PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2.

Several horror games with far higher player counts, such as Lethal Company and Phasmophobia, are missing a Metacritic page in our data, so we have not ranked them. They are worth a look with friends.

Quick answers

What is the best horror game of all time?

In our data, Silent Hill 2 (2024) leads this list on atmosphere and critic score. Alan Wake 2 and Alien: Isolation are the next picks.

What is the best horror game of 2026?

Resident Evil Requiem, with a Metacritic score of 93 in our data. Silver Pines and Reanimal are the strongest smaller picks.

What is the best horror game for beginners?

Little Nightmares II, Dredge or Until Dawn. They are tense without being constantly intense.

Why are some famous horror games missing?

We left out games built around graphic violence, as we want a list of atmosphere and tension. That is an editorial choice, not a quality score.

Sources93 · 85 · 83 · 80 · 78

Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.

Read next · 6 minBest games of 2026 so far: Resident Evil Requiem leads on 93, ranked by critic scoreResident Evil Requiem leads 2026 on our weighted critic score, ahead of Pragmata and Onimusha: Way of the Sword. Nine games, with ratings and the method.

Games in this article

Keep reading