Skip to content
CONSOLYTE
GTA 6
RankingsTime-sensitive

Best story games of 2026 so far: Resident Evil Requiem tops the Metacritic scores

Ten 2026 releases where the story is the reason to play: horror, quiet puzzle tales, spy fiction and a final chapter. Each has a linked score, platforms and a reason to pick it.

CEConsolyte Editors · 12 November 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer

Resident Evil Requiem has the highest Metacritic score of our story picks from 2026. Pragmata, Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy, Esoteric Ebb and Cairn follow. We chose games where the story drives play, and none repeats our earlier cinematic list.

Resident Evil Requiem has the highest linked score of our 2026 story picks, at 93. This list is for games where the story is the reason you keep playing. It does not repeat the games in our cinematic story list. Scores are Metacritic, linked, and we describe stories only in general terms, with no spoilers.

93
Resident Evil Requiem
Top-scored pick
10
Picks
All released in 2026
M
Rating
Several picks are M
0
Spoilers
Here

Sources93

01Which 2026 story games are the biggest?

Key art for Resident Evil RequiemResident Evil Requiem, the ninth main Resident Evil game
Resident Evil Requiem, the ninth main Resident Evil game
Cover art for Resident Evil Requiem

2026 · Horror

Resident Evil Requiem

Metacritic 93. FBI analyst Grace Ashcroft investigates a series of mysterious deaths in the ninth main game. It is survival horror, rated M, so expect fear and violence. On PC, PS5, Xbox Series X|S and Switch 2.

Critic Metacritic939.7 players~8h
Key art for PragmataPragmata, Capcom's sci-fi story of an astronaut and an android
Pragmata, Capcom's sci-fi story of an astronaut and an android
Cover art for Pragmata

2026 · Shooter

Pragmata

Metacritic 89. An astronaut and an android girl try to escape a hostile AI on a lunar station. The story is a two-person journey, and the game design makes you cooperate as a pair. Rated T.

Critic Metacritic899.7 players~10h
Cover art for 007 First Light

2026 · Action-Adventure

007 First Light

Metacritic 84. A young James Bond earns his licence to kill, in an original story from IO Interactive, the makers of Hitman. It is a good pick if you like spy fiction with room to sneak, drive and use gadgets across the world. It follows Bond's origin story.

Critic Metacritic849.0 players~14h

Sources93 · 89 · 84

02Which are the best quiet or emotional stories?

Key art for Planet of Lana II: Children of the LeafPlanet of Lana II, a quiet puzzle platformer with no spoken words
Planet of Lana II, a quiet puzzle platformer with no spoken words
Cover art for Planet of Lana II: Children of the Leaf

Metacritic 83. Lana and her cat-like friend Mui carry on across an alien planet, and nobody speaks. It is short and gentle, and rated E10+, so it is the one to share with an older child.

Critic Metacritic839.3 players~6h
Cover art for Cairn

2026 · Simulation

Cairn

Metacritic 85. Aava is a mountaineer trying to reach the summit of Mount Kami. The story is the climb, planned one handhold at a time, with food and fatigue to manage. Slow and tense, so skip it if you want action.

Critic Metacritic859.4 players~11h
Cover art for Life is Strange: Reunion

2026 · Narrative

Life is Strange: Reunion

Metacritic 73. The finale of Max and Chloe's story, with the choices the series is known for. Rated M. It has the lowest score here, so it is for series fans, and newcomers should know the earlier games matter.

Critic Metacritic738.9 players~12h

Sources83 · 85 · 73

03Which are the best dark or weird stories?

Key art for Resonance: A Plague Tale LegacyResonance: A Plague Tale Legacy, a prequel set in the series' rat-ridden world
Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy, a prequel set in the series' rat-ridden world
Cover art for Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

Metacritic 85. A prequel to A Plague Tale: Innocence, with sneaking, puzzles and light-based tricks against swarms of rats. Rated M. Pick it for a dark, tense story and skip it if you dislike dread.

Critic Metacritic859.2 players~10h
Cover art for Reanimal

2026 · Puzzle

Reanimal

Metacritic 83. From the makers of Little Nightmares: a brother and sister survive a flooded island of hostile creatures, in co-op. It is horror, rated M, and it looks like a bad dream.

Critic Metacritic838.3 players~6h
Cover art for Control Resonant

2026 · Action RPG

Control Resonant

Metacritic 83. A direct sequel to Control, in which you explore a building that changes shape. The story is deliberately strange, so it is best after the first game.

Critic Metacritic839.3 players~20h

Sources85 · 83 · 83

04What is the best story you can talk your way through?

Key art for Esoteric EbbEsoteric Ebb, a Disco Elysium-inspired role-playing game
Esoteric Ebb, a Disco Elysium-inspired role-playing game
Cover art for Esoteric Ebb

2026 · RPG

Esoteric Ebb

Metacritic 85. A Disco Elysium-inspired role-playing game based on a Dungeons & Dragons campaign, in which conflicts are solved by conversation. You play an unlikely hero in a city of strange characters, and dice rolls and your own thoughts shape the telling. It is funny, too. If your idea of a good story is brilliant writing, this is the one. On PC.

Critic Metacritic859.5 players~45h

Sources85

05Which story game should you start with?

Our rules of thumb, which are opinion: pick Resident Evil Requiem or Resonance if you want tension, Planet of Lana II if you want calm, and Esoteric Ebb if you want to read and choose. Cairn is for patient players, and Life is Strange: Reunion is only for people who finished the earlier games.

We think the safest way to choose is by how you want to feel at the end of the evening. Story games are the genre where a bad match wastes the most time, since the whole point is to finish. Check the rating before you buy. Seven of the ten are rated M or T, which our catalogue lists on every game page, and the horror picks are the strongest on tension.

One for each mood

Tense, calm, spy and talky

06How did we choose these ten?

We took 2026 releases in our catalogue with a linked Metacritic score and a clear story focus, and left out games already on our cinematic list. Not every great 2026 game is here: Saros is a bullet-hell game with a story, Onimusha is action first, and Well Dweller has no linked score.

Platform lists come from our catalogue and can lag a new release, so confirm on your store page. Nothing here is a claim about performance or length, which we have not measured. This is an editorial selection, not a formula ranking, and the order is by theme. Descriptions come from our catalogue and the games' own listings, and we have not claimed first-hand play of any of them.

  • ReportedResident Evil Requiem is on Switch 2 as well as PC, PS5 and XboxFrom our catalogue platform list. Check the store for your console.
  • ReportedEsoteric Ebb is PC onlyOur catalogue lists it on PC. Check for console versions.

Quick answers

What is the best story game of 2026?

Resident Evil Requiem has the highest Metacritic score among our story picks, at 93.

What is a good story game for a quiet evening?

Planet of Lana II is short and gentle, and Cairn is slow and tense.

Are these games for children?

Planet of Lana II is rated E10+. Most of the others are rated M, so check ratings.

Is there a story game on PS5 from 2026?

Yes. Resident Evil Requiem, Pragmata, 007 First Light and Resonance are on PS5, per our catalogue.

More story games

Facts checked against the sources tracked on our hub. Confirmed, reported and rumoured claims are labelled.

Read next · 7 minThe Game Awards 2026 nominees: the full list, and GTA VI leadsSix games are up for Game of the Year, GTA VI leads with eight nominations two days before launch, and the show is on 10 December. Every category, with a vote of our own.

Games in this article

Keep reading